Automoderated users, Bureaucrats, checkuser, developer, Interface administrators, Moderators, Administrators
680
edits
Abar 'Ali: Difference between revisions
→Naming
(Adding photo and its caption) |
(→Naming) |
||
| Line 12: | Line 12: | ||
==Naming== | ==Naming== | ||
Regarding the naming of this area as Abar 'Ali, Some [[Sunni]] sources said: Imam 'Ali (a) has dug many wells there.<ref>I'anat al-talibin, Vol.2, P.341.</ref> [[Shia]] sources also said that Imam 'Ali (a) has dug many wells there during the time of the three first caliphs when he did not have an official position; then he endowed them for the pilgrims of hajj and other people.<ref>See: Manasik-I hajj, Abtahi, P.54-5; Chahardah nur-I pak, Vol.12, P.1671-2.</ref> | Regarding the naming of this area as Abar 'Ali, Some [[Sunni]] sources said: Imam 'Ali (a) has dug many wells there.<ref>I'anat al-talibin, Vol.2, P.341.</ref> [[Shia]] sources also said that Imam 'Ali (a) has dug many wells there during the time of the three first caliphs when he did not have an official position; then he endowed them for the pilgrims of hajj and other people.<ref>See: Manasik-I hajj, Abtahi, P.54-5; Chahardah nur-I pak, Vol.12, P.1671-2.</ref> | ||
It is said in some sources that these wells existed even before the [[Prophet (s)|Prophet]]'s (s) migration to Medina, and Imam 'Ali (a), due to the Prophet's (s) order, fought against some tribes of jinn alongside the wells and defeated them harshly. Sunni sources emphasizing on its falsehood, have considered this story as common tales.<ref>See: al-Bahr al-ra'iq, Vol.2, P.555; al-Durr al-mukhtar, Vol.2, P.522-3, Kashf al-khafa', Vol.2, P.418.</ref> "Its content and source has not proven to us", one of contemporary Shia marja's has said about that report.<ref>See: Sirat al-najat, Vol.2, P.451.</ref> | It is said in some sources that these wells existed even before the [[Prophet (s)|Prophet]]'s (s) migration to Medina, and Imam 'Ali (a), due to the Prophet's (s) order, fought against some tribes of jinn alongside the wells and defeated them harshly. Sunni sources emphasizing on its falsehood, have considered this story as common tales.<ref>See: al-Bahr al-ra'iq, Vol.2, P.555; al-Durr al-mukhtar, Vol.2, P.522-3, Kashf al-khafa', Vol.2, P.418.</ref> "Its content and source has not proven to us", one of contemporary Shia marja's has said about that report.<ref>See: Sirat al-najat, Vol.2, P.451.</ref> | ||
=='Ali b. Abi Talib or 'Ali b. Dinar== | =='Ali b. Abi Talib or 'Ali b. Dinar== | ||