Hadith of Shibli: Difference between revisions
Pourghorbani (talk | contribs) |
Pourghorbani (talk | contribs) |
||
| Line 9: | Line 9: | ||
== Hadith of Shibli == | == Hadith of Shibli == | ||
The Hadith of Shibli is a narration attributed to [[Imam Sajjad ( | The Hadith of Shibli is a narration attributed to [[Imam Sajjad (AS)|Imam Zayn al-Abidin (a)]], in which the Imam, in a conversation with Shibli, explains the [[secrets]] and inner meanings of the rites of [[Hajj]]. | ||
This narration was first recorded in the twelfth century AH in the book ''Al-Tuhfah al-Sunniyyah'' by Sayyid Abdullah Jazairi (d. 1173 AH), and Muhaddith Nuri included it in ''Mustadrak al-Wasa'il''; however, it has been stated that due to its absence in ancient sources and its status as a mursal report,{{note|A mursal hadith is a term in hadith studies meaning that the name of the narrator is omitted from the chain of transmission.}} its attribution to Imam Sajjad (AS) is questionable, and its origin lies in Sufi mystical texts.<ref>''Hajj and Umrah in the Quran and Hadith'', p. 285; ''The Hadith of Shibli on the Secrets of Hajj: Shia Narration or Sufi Tale?'', p. 1.</ref> | This narration was first recorded in the twelfth century AH in the book ''Al-Tuhfah al-Sunniyyah'' by Sayyid Abdullah Jazairi (d. 1173 AH), and Muhaddith Nuri included it in ''Mustadrak al-Wasa'il''; however, it has been stated that due to its absence in ancient sources and its status as a mursal report,{{note|A mursal hadith is a term in hadith studies meaning that the name of the narrator is omitted from the chain of transmission.}} its attribution to Imam Sajjad (AS) is questionable, and its origin lies in Sufi mystical texts.<ref>''Hajj and Umrah in the Quran and Hadith'', p. 285; ''The Hadith of Shibli on the Secrets of Hajj: Shia Narration or Sufi Tale?'', p. 1.</ref> | ||